Sonic the Hedgehog #144 [Feb 2005] Butler/Penders/Jensen cover: Sonic takes a flying leap into who knows what or where while Sally and a smidgen of Knuckles look on. Butler/Penders/Jensen frontispiece: a visual demonstration of the M25YL continuity going to pieces. "Mobius 25 Years Later: The Die Is Cast" Story: Ken Penders; Art: Steven Butler; Ink: Jim Amash; Color: Jason Jensen; Lettering: John E. Workman; Enjoying The Ride At Sega's Expense: Robert Lefler and Dyna Lopez. Having paid his respects to Locke in the previous issue, Knuckles informs Lara-Su of a change in company policy: she has the option of being the next Guardian. Her understated response is interrupted by Knuckles saying that her training days will have to wait until he returns from the mission from which he might not in fact return. Not wanting to take "Wait" for an answer, she tells Dad to count her in on the mission. This suggestion is vetoed by a higher court: Lara-Le, who's curious about why Knuckles is rushing to invoke the "'til death do us part" clause in their sort-of-marriage license. Thanks to some quick sweet talking by Knuckles, she's ready to send him on his way toward an uncertain fate in uncertain weather. "Haven't you checked outside?" she asks. "The weather's gotten considerably worse ever since you got back." This is news to Harry the cabbie, who's reading a perfectly dry newspaper in perfectly dry weather waiting for Knuckles to hop in; it's also news to Steve Butler who drew the weather at odds with the dialogue. After a little banter with Sally, Knuckles notices that Lara-Su isn't taking part in the Big Goodbye Scene. Now, if the word "stowaway" isn't flashing in your mind at this point, you haven't read enough bad fiction, watched enough bad movies or television, or read enough comic books. Harry conveys Knuckles to his destination, complaining about the weather that Steven Butler doesn't draw. Maybe if Butler had been paid some "extra quid" over and above Archie's allegedly dismal page rate, he'd have actually given us a visual depiction of "this mess." Unless Harry is referring to working conditions at Archie generally. Despite the fact that we FINALLY get to see some lightning, the ship bearing Sonic, Knuckles, and the Old Farts of Science takes off for Mobius. Cobar informs Sonic, in a speech that reminded me of Professor Farnsworth from "Futurama," that "we simply don't know enough about the storm's nature ... [to] predict the future in regard to specifics, only generalities." Knuckles then freaks as he recognizes that they're in the Badlands, "the most toxic, uninhabited wasteland on all of Mobius." [Insert New Jersey joke here] Sure, NOW Butler gets visually impressive! The party descends into the chamber where the Tachyon Whatsis is stored. Rotor observes that the thing has never been tested but that it should work in theory. That's good enough for Sonic, however. Back on board the ship, Lara-Su re-enters the story. She no sooner gets back on-stage or on-page than she goes to pieces, literally, the same way her old man did in Knuckles #8's "The Gauntlet" at the hands of Enerjak. We get a sense of WHY this is happening as we tune in to Sonic being short-circuited in the Tachyon Thingie; he then disappears before the device can be shut down. So maybe it works like the photographs in the Back To The Future movies: if Sonic didn't exist neither would Lara-Su. Or something. Which could mean that Lara-Su may show up as a contestant on "Who's Your Daddy?" if she ever re-materializes. But not content to leave things at that, and without so much as a "Code Lyoko," Ken HAS to flash back to the placid present to show our blissfully clueless heroes. He also undergirds this with some pseudo-philosophical profundity ... or is it some pseudo-profound philosophy? ... by a determinist Echidna philosopher named "Paracleas." Don't expect me to buy it, I still believe in free will. HEAD: It's taken a year, but Ken has reached a climax with M25YL and the "disappearance" of Sonic. Sort of. Since the appearance of this story, there have been some fans who have wondered why Ken should wrap things up this way, without even a "To Be Continued" text box to let the fans know that such a momentous development will be addressed again ... at some point or other. All you have to do is fast forward to the Sonic-Grams where Mike Pellerito assures Siany Gregory that "we will be doing some more M25YL ... in the future!" with an exclamation point but without saying when they plan to get around to it. My guess is it'll come up in conjunction with S150. So what will we have to deal with in the meantime? According to the preview media, a lot of stand-alone stories, a major story arc featuring Sonic/Shadow/Metal Sonic for some reason, some filler items ("Ever wonder what it's like to be a Swatbot in Dr Robotnik's employ?" Not really, no.), and some more crap featuring Tommy Turtle. The final two panels may have been intended as a poignant suggestion that as momentarily (and uncharacteristically) carefree as the lives of our heroes and heroines may be at the present, they're all in for a boatload of trouble in two and a half decades. Cute idea, but I don't know if it truly works in practice here. I, for one, found it hard to believe that the characters COULD find a carefree moment in their lives the way the comic's been scripted lately, especially the Return to Angel Island arc. Sonic's relationship with Sally is still on the rocks, Knuckles is estranged from his dad; why should these characters catch a break NOW just so Ken can have a nice "ending" to his story? Perhaps it would have been better to have let this cliffhanger simply end ambiguously with a suggestion that it will be resumed some time in the coming year. Ken, to his credit, tries to keep his future vision of Knuckles, Sonic and their respective families in keeping with the past continuity. And frankly, if it weren't for that, it's an open question as to whether anyone would stay interested. When he wandered off into world-building in "Slumber Party," the pacing stumbled badly. And here, his ending is obviously the weakest link. It's too ambiguous and doesn't offer even token assurance that Ken will deal with these matters at a later date. And assurance is what the readers need. I remember that Lara-Su's introduction in this comic was accompanied by some major fan buzz. They knew she was coming and were waiting to greet her. Now with her sudden disintegration (Doesn't anyone disintegrate starting with the head rather than the extremities? And do they really have enough time to process and comment upon what's happening to them?), Ken just simply takes her off the table. I rather doubt that she's making the time trip in tandem with King Sonic, because that would beg the question "Why her and not Knuckles or one of the Old Farts of Science?" This turn of events is not what the Lara-Su fan base was hoping for, and having to endure Editorial's Delphic silence for the next few months isn't going to be easy. Head Score: 5. EYE: One more time: everybody talks about the weather in this arc, but Steve Butler doesn't go out of his way to depict it. You'd think that he would be able to whip out some of the old Will Eisner "spritz" that was one of the visual signatures of the recently-deceased comic pioneer. Other than that, it's great visuals in the service of a story that's momentarily decided to take a vacation. Eye Score:9. HEART: "Father's Day" would be a tough act to follow under any circumstance, and this story has that burden on its back from the beginning. It makes a good move by shifting the emotional focus onto Lara-Su where (if I may editorialize) it should have been all along. But then her pluck at stowing away is rewarded by her ambiguous ending, which is something of a gut-slam to the fans who thought that she was finally getting her props. Since everyone else is more or less going through the motions to get in place for the Cliffhanger Ending, there's not much else to engage the readers emotionally. Heart Score: 4. "Love and Loss" Story: Romy Chacon; Script: Jonathan Gray (uncredited), Art: Jonathan Gray; Ink: Michael Higgins; Coloring: Josh Ray; Lettering: Jonathan Gray (uncredited); Archie Governing Council: Mike Pellerito, Victor Gorelick, Richard Goldwater, Robert Lefler and Dyna Lopez. Every now and then a story appears in the comic that is truer than its content, a story that reveals the inner workings not only of the characters but of the creative process. And thanks to Jonathan Gray's online diary of his working for Archie Comics in general (http://chipandwalter.adiversions.com/), this will act as my point of departure for what has to be the most special review I've ever done because, for once, the curtain has been completely pulled aside. Jonathan has summed up his work on other stories for the comic using such phrases as "This book was very fun to do for a number of reasons. Overall, as far as finished product goes, I think this is one I'm most pleased with so far." For his work on "Love and Loss" he states it eloquently in one word: "AAAAAAAAARRRRGGGGHHHH!!!!!" Charlie Brown couldn't have said it better. Let's get the "plot" out of the way first: it's basically a look at the letters that appear in an advice to the lovelorn column, "Love and Loss," part of the weekly Knothole News newspaper (motto: "We bring the nuts to you!" Yeah, well nuts to you, too!). We get thinly-disguised letters from Bunnie, Mina, and Amy Rose, as well as a dummy letter from Sally who is actually the "Dear Aly" who writes the column. But describing the plot in this way is like saying "Moby-Dick" is about a marine mammal. Admittedly, this is pretty thin soup from the beginning. So Jonathan Gray, realizing that "many pages needed to be rewritten ... personally requested this story having read the original while drawing [Return to Angel Island]." Editor Mike Pellerito agreed to let him take a crack at it. If you have Internet access you might want to read Jonathan's commentary as a companion to this story; it's located at http://chipandwalter.adiversions.com/jongraywb/sonic144.html. If not, I'll do my best to rephrase his experience without missing the highlights. And lowlights. The opening gambit, where the Knothole News arrives and is quickly scooped up by a mob of Mobian females so that the news dealer can supply some needed exposition in dialogue with Sasha, a kitten and one of Rosie's charges, underwent little change. A reference to Hope in Rosie's dialogue was dropped, and the stream in the mid-ground of one of the panels on the first page was supposed to be a cobblestone road. Also, Jonathan's laborious rendering of the hearts in the background of each page was replaced by a more uniform tile pattern of hearts. There was also far more black space in Jonathan's artwork, such as the wall over the fireplace in the next to last panel on the second page before Josh Ray converted them to shojo manga pastels. But let's look at the dialogue before we get down to business. Whereas the writers for the comic have contented themselves to use standard English and mangled accents for characters such as Antoine and Geoffrey (when the writers remember that they DO speak with accents), the nameless newsie speaks in a looser colloquial English, saying things like "Wozzat?" and "Yeah, a' course" and "Call me silly. I ain't silly." Even Sasha asks Rosie "Didja" get a copy of the paper. In the past, some of the dialogue has been a little too proper if not frankly overwritten; I'm thinking especially of Sally's dialogue as an alleged child in "My Secret Guardian" and HawkHawk's horribly overblown Marvel-style declamations in "Freedom Fighters of the Galaxy," though the latter may have been a goof on the Marvel house style. Jonathan has injected some much-needed naturalness into the comic book's dialogue. This is closer to actual speech than what the comic book has usually delivered. It's clear from this first official foray into writing that he's brought a welcome gift for dialogue to the comic. Too bad he doesn't get to use it much as we plunge into the letters themselves. The first one is from Feeling Terribly Alone, aka Bunnie. Her complaint is that she's still not over Antoine. Aly tells her to communicate ... not the easiest thing to do since Ant is part of the Royal Hiatus which is why Sally is tending the front office. That may sound simple enough, and according to Jon this letter needed less tweaking than the rest. Not that there weren't SOME changes: "Instead of concentrating on how Antoine would get verbally nasty with Bunnie, this was edited in the end thankfully and replaced by myself and Mike with Bunnie mentioning how Antoine once loved her for who she was and not what she looked like. Aly's reply was also changed to reflect certain script changes...." The art, despite Jon's loose and comedic style, is neither. Despite the dispassionate tone of the letter, Bunnie is falling apart like a biscuit in a blender. Aside from one panel where it's unclear if she's taking what looks like a suitcase down from a closet shelf or putting it away, the layout is simple and powerful. I've said this once before about a panel featuring Princess Sally in the "Brave New World" special and it bears repeating now: if you don't want to crawl into that last panel and give that girl a hug, check your pulse. We then segue into a letter from Singing The Blues, which of course means it's from Mina, and it posed a problem in the original: "the way it was worded IMO left an opening for another possible love triangle rehash...." And Jon knew the fan scene well enough to realize that "dredging that monster up again is a BIG FAT OMGWTF ARE YOU THINKING NO-NO"! Solution? We still have a love triangle, but the geometry has been relabeled. Jon's method of giving "the Love Triangle Saga the proper closure it never really had" (and never WOULD have if the worshipers of Loose Continuity had anything to say about it) is to change the Sonic-Sally-Mina triangle into a Mina- Sonic-Ash triangle: "I changed the letter to reflect on her internal conflict between Ash and Sonic and provided a way for her to finally make up her mind." It was a brilliant solution to the problem in that it put the burden of choosing on Mina's shoulders rather than on Sonic's. And thanks to Jon's artwork we see that while Mina thinks Sonic is way past cool, she thinks that Ash is "todo caliente," which is my dime-store Spanish way of saying "a total hottie." Suddenly the contest becomes no contest. This is underscored by Mina's blowing a call in to Ash wanting "to talk," and arranging a midnight rendezvous. "The scene," Jon informs us, "was also changed entirely. What was originally a panel or two turned into six ... because I felt the reader needed to see that Mina was actually making a concerted effort to call ... Ash and ... should see all the reactions from Ash as he talks to her.... I felt this approach was a lot more personable than the standard 'Let's date' call the original had...." If I have any reservations about this sequence, it's that all it would take would be an arch of one eyebrow to turn Ash's expression from "Cool, I think she likes me" to "Cool, I think I'm gonna get lucky!" Silly me! This is an Archie Comic book! If none of the kids at Riverdale High have gotten lucky over the past half- century, then Mina is in absolutely no danger of trading in her sports bra for a nursing bra any time soon. So, on to the letter by Wishing For Love, aka Amy Rose. According to Jonathan, this letter was "[one] of the largest rewrites of the entire story. Beside the last line and the first two lines, everything else in between was totally thrown out." And why was this the case? Consider the following: "The original letter, while concentrating on Sonic, also had Amy throwing hints at Tails which was just TOTALLY out of left field and OOC IMHO." But wait, there's more: "As a character all her own, Amy has never really been developed in the book, and since this is really the first time we've ever gotten into her head at all I wanted to make it worth something. Naturally her longtime crush on Sonic is paramount but how would she feel considering she's in-between an acerbic Sally and a lovestruck Mina? So that's the point of the original letter I decided to concentrate on. If that was me, how would I feel. While Amy's reaction to Aly's response was the same as it was originally written I also took some time to tweak Aly's response to show that Amy's gonna always do her own thing regardless. The 'Buy a clue' line was all me though." You know, I never, ever, EVER thought I'd read where a writer for the comic complained that some action or speech by a character was OOC, shorthand for "out of character." Bushels of horror have been perpetrated on these characters without regard as to whether anything OOC was happening. It's been years since Sonic #61's "Outback Gut Check," and the memory of Mike Gallagher's having Barby Koala declare her lust for Tails STILL creeps me out! Perhaps it's because Jonathan Gray came up through the fan ranks rather than by way of the comic industry's old boy network but here we have an artist given a chance to write and guess what: he GETS IT!! A story such as this one HAS to be character-driven, and he gets it! His line about how "Amy has never really been developed in the book" deserves the Understatement of the Year Award. This comic has been absolutely awful when it comes to character development, which has been one of my most consistent gripes since I started doing this on a regular basis. Then again, almost anything would look good compared to the potential horror of what (justly) landed on the cutting room floor. Any Rose and Tails? No freakin' way!! I'm surprised that wasn't nipped in the bud by Leffler and Lopez, the Sega reps of record. Killer zombie hamsters would have made more sense than Amy Rose and Tails! This letter is definitely lighter in tone than the two preceding, and while Jonathan doesn't engage in the exaggerated gestures that seemed sometimes out of place in his Archie work, you can tell he's having fun here with Amy Rose's "gag me" gesture in response to what she's reading. Great. Now we come to the Sally letter, which Jonathan admits he "had to rewrite ... a number of times before I was finally happy with it." "Sally's [letter] was the hardest to do" because "[t]he wording in the original was cliche and rather than focus on what was one of the most volatile plot points since she was tossed off a building ... I didn't think [the fans] would be happy with any kind of approach at all. The real problem was coming up with a way to tackle this issue without splitting Sonic and Sally permanently, making the gap an even wider one, or not doing anything about it at all thus turning this whole section into a space waster." Since Jonathan found himself facing the fact that Sally's blow-up at Sonic in S134 came out of nowhere with no real motivation whatever, "I used her letter and 'Aly's' response to it to get inside Sally's head and not focus on this sudden mean streak, but rather [to focus on] WHY she made the decision she did." Of course, this makes way too much dramatic sense plus it completely violates the laws of Loose Continuity, which explains why we haven't seen it in the comic since Sally dropped her drama bomb 10 issues ago. "Sally's primary dillema [sic] is that she wants to be happy and can very well accept her responsibility as a princess - but when she tries to mix the two suddenly she finds constant conflict. Living her own life isn't as natural to her as leading a rebellion or leading her people because that's all she's ever known since being a small child. So now she's on the road to discovering how to do that. And that's the way of thinking that I took when I wrote her letter/response. I can only hope that in some ways it worked." When, WHEN was the last time any of the writers were able to discuss any of the characters with this level of comprehension? This is how the FANS think about the characters, maybe not with the same level of sympathy (in the case of the anti-Sally faction), but with that kind of depth and maturity. This is why there are times I want the fans to revolt and take over the comic; it's obvious that the professionals are beginning to lose a step. And if you don't believe me, consider what was supposed to be the final page of this story, where Sally reveals that she planted the letter as a dodge. Here is the original ending by faux-Romy. Brace yourselves: "In the original ending, Sally broke the fourth wall and began talking to the reader. DIRECTLY from the script: (P1) 'Oh hello, were you expecting someone else, perhaps?' (P2) Oh, the letter from me? To throw anyone else who may think Allie is Sally. (P3) After all, my secrets are made public for all the world to see. Well, maybe not all my secrets. (p4)Why do I do this in my free time? A girl's got to have a hobby, you know.' END. And yes - that's the original ending to Love and Loss WORD FOR WORD." Jon admits to being "indifferent" about the ending. For me it was utter disbelief verging on a strong impulse to crumple up the page and swallow it so nobody would ever have to look at it again. And Archie PAID for this?!? I'm sorry. This is painfully bad writing! So Jon asked to rewrite the story and Mike did what any conscientious editor would do and green-lighted the rewrite. The first time Jon kept the breaking-the-fourth-wall conceit out of wondering how far he could go. End of story? The fun was just beginning. Several weeks later Mike tells Jon that the page has to be redrawn. As the conversation continued, Mike and Jon realize they're on the same page (as it were) concerning the need to tighten up the writing of the page even more. Jon's rewrite is available for your inspection as a WordPad document through his site. It didn't get into the comic because ... HURRICANE FRANCES ATE MY HOMEWORK! In what has to be the weirdest twist in the tale of any writer's quest, Jon ... well, I'll let him explain: "Since I was at my cousins house for the weekend, I mailed off both page 11 and the newly drawn page 10 the day after Francis had hit Atlanta and thought nothing of it. But in what is probably the most bonehead thing I've ever seen, Mike called me up to inform me that when he got the package Page 11 was ruined in the rain. I asked him how and it seems that the package had arrived just before a holiday. Whoever delivered the mail to Archie left the package out in front of the building on the stoop. That's simple enough, right? Well - by that time Hurricane Francis had dwindled down into a major thunder/rainstorm and hit New York/New Jersey THE DAY MY PACKAGE ARRIVED. Since no one was available at Archie to pick it up due to the national holiday, for three days Pages 10 and 11 were rained on. And the only reason that Page 10 survived was because Page 11 was sitting on top of it in the package. Both pages had to air out in his office for several days before Mike Higgins could even touch them." OK. Seems clear enough. My guess is that at the less-than- palatial Archie Comics HQ (basically a warehouse with editorial offices on the second floor), there's a mail slot that will accommodate regular #10 mailing envelopes. But this can't be the only time someone has had to mail artwork to them. So I have to wonder: IS ARCHIE COMICS SO STINKIN' CHEAP THAT THEY WON'T EVEN POP FOR THE RENTAL ON A FREAKIN' POST OFFICE BOX??? "With a ruined page and deadline for print fast approaching," Jon continues, "Mike did the only thing he could do and amalgamated the second ending with the page designed to fit the original [breaking the] fourth wall ending ... considering everything else, Mike Pellerito is a miracle worker because I would have spontaneously combusted on the spot after dealing with everything else." I can relate. Two small details need to be pointed out. There is no credited letterer in this story because for the most part none was needed. "Aly"'s replies to the letters appear in an obvious type face such as Courier or Times New Roman. As for the letters themselves, they were done in one of the several "hand-written" fonts available. With all due respect to people such as John E. Workman, I'm surprised that the American comic industry still employs letterers. Japanese manga went to computer-generated type decades ago, but that was mainly due to the complexity of the written language, which incorporates Chinese characters or "kanji," two different phonetic scripts, and the occasional Roman alphabet letters. Pick any letter, ANY letter, upper or lower case, from the letters to Aly and you'll find that they're absolutely identical. You can use this same trick to expose what appears to be hand-written junk mail from marketers and so on. Finally, there's the ending, which all things considered is good. But there's just something weird about a story that deals with relationship problems and then has nobody in the story actually relating with anybody else, except for Mina and Ash. Everyone else is off in their own space doing their own thing. I can't help but think that if Sally was perceptive enough to recognize where her friend Bunnie was coming from in her letter, that she'd actually show up on Bunnie's doorstep and BE THERE FOR HER instead of just letting it go. And she could have done so without blowing her cover as "Aly." But that's just armchair quarterbacking on my part. Jon Gray deserves the admiration and respect of Sonic readers for letting us know just how much of a nuthouse it can be while still asserting that "COMIC BOOKS ARE FUN!!!!" DATA-FILE: The Acorn Royal Family. So what do you do when the last page of your back story gets rained on and you're one page short of a comic book? Data-File to the rescue! This is a cheap way to bring the newbies up to speed on a plot point or two. Unfortunately, it gives us the What while easing off on the Why. We knew nothing about how Elias and Meg (aka Megan) got together or even who the father of Alexis is. The Data-file does nothing to shed light on any of the Loose Continuity nuggets of the past, which would have made the page helpful and not just a waste of space. The artwork, however, is just a hair short of unforgivable. It's an uninspired pastiche of drawings including some lifted from a number of the "magazine-style covers": Elias was lifted from the cover of S121, and Sally from S123. The drawing itself is uncredited, which is understandable because I don't know who in their right mind would WANT to be saddled with this work on their resume. I've seen Jon Gray's concept art for Ash and know that he had to lose the arm tats before he could see the light of day. Tattooed fur is one thing, but a furry with a five-o-clock shadow? Wassup with THAT?!? It doesn't just look like dirt, it looks ridiculous! I know this was an emergency, Mike, but next time try running a Data-File that actually contains data. Fan Art: Seven more examples including Sonic and Tails at the beach by Scott Moore, Sonic Battle Tails by Edward Richman, and Sonic and Shadow with anorexia by Isabel Melendez. Then there's Jessica Malanowski's drawing of Sonic, Tails, Knuckles and Amy with someone else's hair. I'll be the first to admit it: I don't get the joke. Sonic-Grams: I'll just hit the highlights from Mike: Tails will be featured in S147-151, presumably NOT married to Mina or courting Amy Rose; and there'll be a Sonic X mini-series coming in the summer which will be violently attacked by some readers if the writers managed to work Chris into the script. And kudos for the library references. Editorial: Even Mike Pellerito concedes that "Tails and Mina marrying seem[s] almost impossible" but that didn't stop it from getting into the comic. Mike then proceeds to embarrass himself by declaring "Yours is the opinion that really matters! If all the fans of this book demand that we put Sonic in a dress, you can guess the blue blur will be in a dress." I was a little concerned when I first read this, but then realized that Mike wasn't being exactly straightforward about his willingness to be a vox pop whore. For one thing, there's no way to get "all the fans" to agree on pretty much anything, let alone wanting to see Sonic in a "La Cage aux Folles" crossover. Then there's the little matter of Gorelick, Goldwater, the Sega Licensing reps, and the Comic Code Authority to make sure Sonic in a dress is the LAST thing that will appear in the comic. Finally, Mike says "You can guess the blue blur will be in a dress." Not "you can BET...." We can make that guess right now, and it would be a wrong guess, in any event. So don't read too much into the editorial, gang. Off-Panel: when I was in college they didn't toss pencils at the ceiling. They tossed gummi bears. More interesting color effect.